myforumyork Posted February 28, 2020 Posted February 28, 2020 Hey there, I've been looking to get rhinoplasty and facial contouring surgery in Korea for the past 2 years. I've researched clinics on Purseforum, Korean websites such as Naver (I'm not Korean, I can just read the language and understand a little bit - what I don't understand, I translate with an online translator). During the two years, I have made a list of clinics that I would personally avoid, either because of botched results or no safety regulations. This is my own personal opinion. I advise each individual to conduct their own research and see what clinics they prefer. I am in no way a professional. Just looking to help people out. The list shows like this:Clinic Name Date of source (MM/DD/YYYY) (SOURCE) Link to source Teuim 12.08.2017 Girl says her fat-graft did not go well and that her eyelid surgery is just okay source: https://beautyhacker.com/forums/topic/976415-1-year-after-des-epi-teuim-fat-graft-fresh-advice/Regen 11.08.2018 Girls says that Regen messed up her v-line and her nerve is too exposed now. Another commenter said that their thread-lifting experience was not good Many mixed reviews on purseblog (proceed with caution) source: https://beautyhacker.com/forums/topic/999133-avoid-regen-at-all-costs/Grand 03.11.2015 Korean High School Student goes on comma and eventually died while doing eye and nose surgery. Grand tried to hide the news and taking down any posting or news made online. But a TV documentary MBC PD's Note made an episode (Episode 993) about the accident details and they even manage to interview on some ex-surgeons and ex-nurses who was there on the day of accident. source:https://m.post.naver.com/viewer/postView.nhn?volumeNo=2797577&memberNo=3471622Grand/Opera/HERSHE 12.25.2013 False advertisement “Therefore, the Fair Trade Commission announced on August 22 that it has corrected 13 plastic surgery hospitals and clinics that mislead consumers with false and exaggerated advertisements through internet homepages and banner advertisements. In addition, the plastic surgeons and clinics who have been caught issued a public order on the homepage to clarify that they received corrective orders. The FTC advised that even if you are not a plastic surgeon under the Medical Law, it is necessary to confirm whether or not a plastic surgeon is treating a cosmetic surgery in order to reduce damages such as cosmetic side effects, considering that a doctor's license qualifies for cosmetic surgery.” Corrective measures for 13 PS clinics source:http://www.seoulcity.co.kr/news/articleView.html?idxno=64950 Korean PS (Closed) Izien Plastic Surgery Korean (Closed) Orange Clinic Romian PS Lapians Clinic Opera PS HERSHE Ping Clinic Star Fleur DMIPS Korea Plastic Surgery Grand Plastic Surgery Wonjin 09.05.2019 A woman who underwent eye surgery at a famous plastic surgery in Seoul cannot open her right eye properly for six months after surgery. In the news, Plastic Surgery is shown in mosaic, but this is undoubtedly Wonjin. source: View 09.04.2019 Leaked tens of thousands of customer information. The customer's real name, mobile phone number and consultation details were leaked source: ID 06.07.2017 "No accident for 14 years" is a lie. The hospital name is not disclosed in this news, but it is said to be ID in Korea. A Korean woman died in a contour surgery. The hospital tampered with her chart. source:https://news.sbs.co.kr/news/endPage.do?news_id=N1004281235 12.06.2018 “A staff member of ID Hospital (ID Plastic Surgery) who leaked a plastic video of a celebrity customer was confirmed to have left the hospital.” source: http://www.topdaily.kr/news/articleView.html?idxno=56110#098P 03.12.2016 Facial contour surgery botched source: https://web.archive.org/web/20160412191807/https://www.realself.com/review/hospital-south-korea-gangnam-district-orthognathic-surgery-korea-hospitalJewelry 03.16.2015 Jewelry plastic surgery has done a birthday party in the operating room where the patient lies. source:http://www.ntoday.co.kr/news/articleView.html?idxno=28956 07.27.106 tax evasion source:http://www.bosa.co.kr/news/articleView.html?idxno=607280TL PS 01.24.2017 It's a fire accident in an operating room. source: http://www.ytn.co.kr/_ln/0103_201701240015513326 Members on purseblog say they got their ps done by Dr.Choi from TLPS and hates it source: https://beautyhacker.com/forums/topic/989495-blacklist-of-the-korean-plastic-surgery/page-3GNG 05.22.2018 Some girls surgery was botched, they cut too much of her jawbone and weren’t listening to her requests, although she provided a lot of pictures showing the results that she wished to achieve. source: https://beautyhacker.com/forums/topic/988280-gng-hospital-stay-away-at-all-costs/BK 07.20.2012 tax evasion source:http://news.chosun.com/site/data/html_dir/2012/07/20/2012072000102.htmlJW 04.08.2015 “Jin Weikun, a native of Shanxi, a fashion trainer, model, and actor, victim of the South Korean JW Plastic Hospital. Last June, she united more than a dozen victims in South Korea to carry out collective rights protection, and they separately negotiated with the hospital that implemented the plastic surgery, but all came back to nothing.” “My chin was trimmed without formal consent 11In November 2013, Jin Weikun was attracted by a plastic reality show called "Wish List 2" called the Chinese version of Let Beauty, and he signed up to participate. Become a member of free plastic surgery in Korea. 1On January 14, 2014, she did a nipple reconstruction at the JW Plastic Hospital. Three days later, another face-lifting operation was performed, and 12 operations were performed in one day, including chin reshaping that Jin Weikun did not formally agree to. On the 4th of the following month, Jin Weikun did fat filling and areola tattooing again. After the operation, Jin Weikun noticed a crooked face. CT examination showed that the cheekbones were wide and narrow, the nose prosthesis was crooked, the bones of the nasolabial pad were asymmetric, and the angle of the jaw was asymmetric. After diagnosis, all facial operations failed, and the purpose of the operation may be to train hands.” source: http://sh.eastday.com/m/20150408/u1ai8658579.htmlFaceline 04.08.2015 “At that time, the domestic "very beautiful network" recommended two Korean hospitals, Yuan Chen and Zhu Erli. Wu Yuanyuan visited the two hospitals under the leadership of the website. Because the price was too high, she found the FaceLine hospital on the TV show. On September 16, 2013, Wu Yuanyuan underwent a nose and hairline down surgery at FaceLine Plastic Surgery Hospital. A severe infection occurred immediately after the operation. After 2 months of anti-inflammatory treatment, a large scar of more than 20 cm in length was left on the forehead. The upper part of the scalp became unconscious and the hair fell off a lot. He underwent repair surgery on December 4, 2013 and June 19, 2014, respectively, and the repair failed. Wu Yuanyuan negotiated with the hospital on several occasions to defend his rights. The hospital blatantly slandered that he suffered from serious mental disorders and syphilis, and even used violence against him. He was repeatedly sent to the police station.” source: http://sh.eastday.com/m/20150408/u1ai8658579.htmlSecret/Faceline/Cinderella/Opera/Odyssey 09.21.2017 “Seven hospitals and clinics, including Opera Plastic Surgery, Dr. Holmes, Kangnam Peter Hospital, Odyssey Dental Clinic, Pop Plastic Surgery, Cinderella Plastic Surgery, and Pohair, received false corrections and introductions. Secret and Faceline Plastic Surgery posted photo before and after molding on the homepage and maximized the molding effect by putting the model face on the pictures after the molding and wearing circle lenses and shooting in a professional studio. Secret plastic surgery deceived consumers by using the phrase, “holding 10,000 or more surgical know-hows” without any objective evidence. Opera Plastic Surgery, Dr. Holmes, Gangnam Peter Hospital, and Odyssey Dental Clinic have allegedly posted false posts on blogs and Internet cafés that the advertising agency actually treated at the hospital. Cinderella Plastic Surgery and Pohair Clinic have posted their introductions and recommendations on external blogs without notifying them that they have been written by hospital staff.” source: https://news.joins.com/article/21956660April31 12.2018 (P.S date - not sure) NadineP had her rhinoplasty revision done from April31 Surgery was botched source: https://beautyhacker.com/members/nadinep.620890/
huongkhanmoon Posted March 2, 2020 Posted March 2, 2020 thanks for creating this thread. I feel like there are not many reliable clinics left though
chococatx Posted March 3, 2020 Posted March 3, 2020 IOU: high possibility for another eye revision I also went there for consult, and got the vibe they just want your money and uncooperative. Source: https://beautyhacker.com/forums/topic/1005406-going-back-to-seoul-soon-for-possible-third-revision-thoughts-on-these-clinics/#post-32914275
gqwiththesteez Posted March 3, 2020 Posted March 3, 2020 IMO every clinic is going to have a dissatisfied customer simply on numbers. I've seen a few of those sources and would have to agree. But the thread you shared on Regen I posted on and I even asked Dr. Oh about that particular patient. There is a reason she does not share pictures on PS and Real self. She actually did post on Real self but everyone was complimenting her pics which went against her 'negative review'.
rhunapo886 Posted March 3, 2020 Posted March 3, 2020 wow so what are the good clinics to now choose from thanks for sharing
myforumyork Posted March 4, 2020 Author Posted March 4, 2020 ** UPDATE ** (Again, every clinic has good and bad reviews. Whoever is reading should make their own decisions based on which clinic/doctor they choose. The only reason I post these clinics is not because of the result- which can differ from patient to patient- but things like clinics not doing proper aftercare if the surgery goes wrong, or forging documents.)Namu 01.25.2019@ifterms has permanent brow loss and scarring (Dr. Kirk botched a brow lift), and the clinic also apparently forged documents. source: https://beautyhacker.com/members/ifterms.661292/Braun 07.21.2017@Height received rhinoplasty, which 2 years later, resulted in uneven incision scar and a big depression on one side of the nose. Now, they brush her off when she tries to contact them. source: https://beautyhacker.com/members/height.504002/02.12.2018 @hohohalmoni stated that "Last year I also went to Braun for a butterfly implant consultation (a procedure that is done by inserting butterfly-shaped silicon implants into the sunken area next to the alars to improve smile lines and flat cheeks) that only they proceed, but they were rude and pushy about me putting a deposit, so I immediately crossed them off the list." source: https://beautyhacker.com/forums/topic/885801-theline-plastic-surgery-just-fishished/page-13#post-3204370703.06.2017 @mirabelle7 stated "Wow that's shocking to know. I actually considered Braun for FC but no way am I letting them rip me off A friend of mine had her primary rhino done at Braun. Not sure how much she paid but the result was too masculine for her liking and she ended up having a revision done." source: https://beautyhacker.com/forums/topic/948429-need-to-know-braun-prices/page-3#post-31131204
pepelau Posted March 4, 2020 Posted March 4, 2020 Thanks for sharing this, but just in my opinion, there is no clinic with 100% satisfied clients, nowhere in the world. According to your list, all english - speaking clinics must be avoided because one or two people said that they don't like the result or because of 2-7 years old news, some of which don't even state clinics names (?). And I totally agree with your advise on doing personal research, I would also recommend rely on face-to-face consultations and your feeling after it.
silverneedle Posted March 17, 2020 Posted March 17, 2020 Thanks for compiling this list. This thread should be pinned imo. please also add clinics with death: Ollim , mvp, jaejun, wonjin, before and after. grand and wonted had deaths too bu you already mentioned them source: https://beautyhacker.com/forums/topic/979623-the-clinics-that-has-0-medical-accidents-for-bone-contouring/#post-32026542https://beautyhacker.com/forums/topic/1025738-for-awareness-another-surgery-clinic-death/ Death at MVP mentioned in miss orange's thread
silverneedle Posted March 17, 2020 Posted March 17, 2020 I also know from experience that one popular clinic mentioned here is very not recommended. I wish I hadn't completely believed all the glowing reviews. to anyone reading this, if you see a glowing review on purse forum, please don't believe it that easily. look up the clinic's name using the search bar and read every post that comes up. pay more attention to the negative reviews than the positive ones. also, check the post history of the reviewer. in fact many popular clinics have staff that are constantly monitoring purse forum and kakao ps groups. I respectfully disagree with other posters here that say all clinics will have unsatisfied clients anyway. most of the time botched results are caused by clinics that try to do as many surgeries as possible in a day. the exception is when someone is unsatisfied because the result is too natural or too dolly. this is not botched, only a matter of the doctor's style not matching your preferred aesthetic.
ebichu7 Posted March 17, 2020 Posted March 17, 2020 I totally agree with you. I noticed some people call it this way. Botched is something done WRONG, aesthetics can't be wrong. That's why it's so important to do research well, check before and after, so we end up looking as close as we can to our ideal version of ourselves.
autheree Posted March 22, 2020 Posted March 22, 2020 Add this to the list too! This clinic is called Small Face clinic.https://www.koreaboo.com/stories/korean-plastic-surgeon-leaves-patient-bleed-death-gory-cctv-footage-will-shock/
)
Recommended Posts